Before the punkmusic.com site, they had an official geocities site that got updated with news. (It’s the URL that’s in the Shut Your Mouth liner notes, presumably even in new copies still.) The last design I remember for it was the devil with his hands out like on the back of SYMAOYE, except the song titles were replaced with “News”, “Tourdates”, “Discography”, etc. A dude named Bob Roth ran it before William took over for the punkmusic.com era. I don’t know when the geocities site officially started, but a version of it already existed when I got into AFI in late 96.
I don’t have pictures of it, but you might be able to dig some stuff up from the archive.org wayback machine.