AFI Song Stats: #MourninginAmerika 2018

This thread is reserved for song stats during AFI’s Mourning in Amerika tour 2018.

Top Chart: Current


  1. 17 Crimes (Burials) x 7
  2. A Single Second (Shut Your Mouth And Open Your Eyes)
  3. Aurelia (Blood Album) x 3
  4. Beautiful Thieves (Crash Love) x 6
  5. Bleed Black (Sing the Sorrow) x 3
  6. Dancing Through Sunday (Sing the Sorrow) x 2
  7. Days of the Phoenix (The Art of Drowning) x 5
  8. Dumb Kids (Blood Album)
  9. End Transmission (Crash Love) x 2
  10. Endlessly, She Said (Decemberunderground)
  11. Every and a Day (The Art of Drowning)
  12. Feed From the Floor (Blood)
  13. Get Hurt (Blood)
  14. Girl’s Not Grey (Sing the Sorrow) x 12
  15. He Who Laughs Last (Very Proud of Ya)
  16. Heart Stops (Burials)
  17. I Hope You Suffer (Burials) x 9
  18. Killing Lights (Decemberunderground)
  19. Lost Souls (The Art of Drowning) x 3
  20. Love Like Winter (Decemberunderground) x 7
  21. Malleus Maleficarum (Black Sails in the Sunset)
  22. Miss Murder (Decemberunderground) x 14
  23. No Poetic Device (Black Sails in the Sunset) x 3
  24. Of Greetings and Goodbyes (The Art of Drowning) x 3
  25. Paper Airplanes (Sing the Sorrow) x 11
  26. Perfect Fit (Very Proud of Ya)
  27. Rabbits are Roadkill on Route 37 (MySpace Records Comp - B Side)
  28. Sacrifice Theory (The Art of Drowning)
  29. Silver and Cold (Sing the Sorrow) x 3
  30. Snow Cats (Blood Album) x 11
  31. So Beneath You (Blood Album) x 4
  32. Still A Stranger (Blood)
  33. Strength Through Wounding (Black Sails in the Sunset) x 2
  34. Summer Shudder (Decemberunderground) x 4
  35. The Last Kiss (Black Sails in the Sunset)
  36. The Nephilim (The Art of Drowning)
  37. This Celluloid Dream (Sing the Sorrow) x 6
  38. Totalimmortal (All Hallows EP) x 2
  39. Veronica Sawyer Smokes (Crash Love)
  40. Wester (The Art of Drowning) x 2
  41. Ziggy Stardust (Bowie cover)


  1. Sing the Sorrow x 7 songs played x 35 times total
  2. The Art of Drowning x 7 songs played x 13 times total
  3. Decemberunderground x 5 songs played x 26 times total
  4. Blood Album x 7 songs played x 21 times total
  5. Burials x 3 songs played x 17 times total
  6. Crash Love x 3 songs played x 9 times total
  7. Black Sails in the Sunset x 5 songs played x 7 times total
  8. Shut Your Mouth And Open Your Eyes x 1 song played 1 time
  9. All Hallows EP x 1 song(s) played x 2 time(s) total
  10. Very Proud of Ya x 2 song(s) played x 2 time(s) total
  11. Covers x 1 played 1 time
  12. B-Sides x 1 played 1 time

NOTE: Songs that have no numbers beside them have only been played once so far on this tour*

Updated with 09/13/18 set list. (except charts - coming)

Percentages by album for first leg (accurate as of 8/11/2018)

  • Sing the Sorrow: 28.57%
  • Decemberunderground: 20%
  • Blood: 14.29%
  • Burials: 13.34%
  • Art of Drowning: 12.38%
  • Crash Love: 5.71%
  • Black Sails in the Sunset: 3.81%
  • All Hallows EP: 0.95%
  • Very Proud of Ya: 0.95%

(Percentages added by @Sayasha)

Percentages for the 2nd leg (up to date as of 10/1):

  • Sing the Sorrow: 21.8%
  • decemberunderground: 17.8%
  • Blood: 14.9%
  • Art of Drowning: 10.9%
  • Burials: 10.9%
  • Crash Love: 8%
  • Black Sails in the Sunset: 6.9%
  • All Hallows: 3.4%
  • B-sides/covers: 2.3%
  • Very Proud of Ya: 1.7%
  • 3 1/2: >1%
  • Shut your Mouth and Open Your Eyes: >1%

I find it strange that they only play one song from their newest album. I mean, I would much rather see This Celluloid Dream or Paper Airplanes any time over So Beneath You or Aurelia, but I would trade GNG or TDOTP if I get to see Above The Bridge or Get Hurt.

They continue to play STS songs heavily (I’m guessing) because they have the bigger audiences.

They played mainly STS songs last year too. There were a few times where other albums came close or tied, but it’s mainly STS.

1 Like

That, and TAOD. Of Greetings and Goodbyes has been a really great surprise, so as the comeback of The Lost Souls. I’m also glad they dropped TLSP2, Dancing Through Sunday and sometimes even Silver and Cold, for songs like This Celluloid Dream and Paper Airplanes.

If someone told me during the DU era that they’d be playing songs like He Who Laughs Last, Paper Airplanes or Salt For Your Wounds, I would have told them they were crazy.

I updated the first post with a fancy chart. Will update again after tonight’s show!

1 Like

I love fancy charts! And because it’s hard to tell on the internet I really am not being sarcastic. I really love charts and graphs.


I’ll be updating as soon as we get the setlist from tonight.

Awesome work,they are playing and keeping the sets interesting,I predict bsides and lesser played songs from crash love album and the bsides we got from the deluxe edition.So many possibilities.Doesn’t the tour go on break for about a month soon or did they fill those dates

1 Like

It looks like they have a break from August 11th to September 6th when they pick up again. So there will be a bit of a break (because really, who wants to tour during the hottest part of August?)

That’s a long break logistically renting the buses and trucks for the short term,but I noticed the venues when the pickup in sept are “sheds” aka amphitheaters so it may be very hard to come in contact with them in sheds.Hopefully Afi has something up the sleeve ,maybe Continue work on studio material as it seems they were doing when jades guitar ad popped up . fingers crossed

1 Like

On the graph it’s only got 2 songs from crash love but they’ve played 3 (beautiful thieves, end transmission and Veronica sawyer)

1 Like

Thanks! The top graph is right but the one right below is wrong. I’ll correct it. :slight_smile:

EDIT: I also corrected Crash Love at the bottom under “Albums” to correlate with the mistake/correction.

1 Like

Because I love percentages here are some rough ones:
Sing the sorrow: 30%
Art of drowning: 10%
Decemberunderground: 18.75%
Blood: 15%
Burials: 12.5%
Black Sails:3.75%
All Hallows: 1.25%
VPOY: 1.25%
Crash Love: 7.5%

1 Like

Thank you! I’ll admit I’m rough with percentages… it’s one of those tools I use every now and again.

You should add this to the first post. :slight_smile:

When I have some time to sit down and make sure it’s 100% accurate I will! I love percentages!

1 Like

Updated the main post with album percentages! If anyone knows how to make a sweet pie graph of it please feel free!

1 Like

Love it! Thank you! I updated both charts and the lists shortly after getting the setlist from @Cher_I_Despair. Thanks to his friend who sent him the setlist. :slight_smile:

EDIT: I’m going to put them in order from highest to lowest. So STS at the top and All Hallows and VPOY at the bottom.

EDIT again: bottom chart is missing VPOY. I’ll correct tomorrow after work. VPOY would be at 1 for “He Who Laughs Last”.

1 Like

edited to update percentages :smiley:

@sayasha I updated all numbers, EXCEPT ALL CHARTS… we gotta update them yet.

1 Like

I’m kind of waiting for the second leg to be done to recompile all my percentages. That way I can make a second leg chart and then a chart for the first and second leg together

1 Like